Skip to content
Ann Smarty

SEO Consulting

  • Infographic Link Building Service
  • Content Marketing Services
  • Guest Blogging Services
  • Contact
Ann Smarty
SEO Consulting
Home / Digital Marketing Ethics / Negative Voting – I Am Ann Smarty and I’m Thumboholic

Negative Voting – I Am Ann Smarty and I’m Thumboholic

Negative VotingLike I said previously, social media is not all about friends and mutual help. It might also trigger unreasoned hatred, misinterpretation and misunderstanding. Well, fellow Mozzers might have noticed my highly negative attitude towards SEOMoz thumb down system; so recent discussions over there inspired me to post my opinion on general negative voting across the social media. It’s not that I am against disapproval or criticism in general – no, I am not going to put the necessity of negative voting under question – my main point is that negative voting should make sense.

What does a thumb down mean?

Different social networks treat thumbs down differently. In general, the role of voting down in social media site algorithm can be divided into three major groups (depending on the direct impact on an individual submission): active role, passive role and… well… something in-between.

Active role: a thumb down contributes to ‘burying‘ the submission (= no one will see it; an active role of general community news sorting)
Example: Digg

Passive role: a thumb down only shows a member’s attitude (no automatic impact on the post; though this might be added to a submitter’s record)
Example: SEOMoz

Intermediate role: a thumb down tells the system that the submission (and the like) is not relevant to you personally (and to like-minded people) (= don’t show things like this to me and my friends; but this is not necessarily a generally bad post)
Example: StumbleUpon

*Note: StumbleUpon algorithm has been up for debate recently; I have no official evidence to support this (like they say “The thumb down will also lessen the likelihood of your friends stumbling this content“), my assumptions are based on my personal experience and investigation.

What is the process of thumbing down?

Process of thumbing down

Now what is the process of negative voting?

1/ Anonymous thumbs down (it can be either commented, or just left as it is) = the community doesn’t know who thumbed down the post (e.g. SEOMoz)

Advantages: people are free to show their negative attitude;

Drawbacks: beside being rather pointless (most often it does not mean/show/tell anything to a member), this kind of negative voting seems potentially dangerous to the overall community atmosphere and behavior: (1) it encourages ‘biased promotion/discrimination’ based solely on personal attitude (= I don’t like this person, so I will thumb him down no matter what he/she says); (2) it can limit members in their freedom of expressing their own independent opinion (e.g. members feel uneasy to voice their (opposite to the community’s) opinion at the fear to be thumbed down ‘scot-free‘); (3) it may be unfair (as often it is ruled by emotion, that’s only a one-click action!).

2/ Non anonymous (with no compulsory comment/explanation) – example: Mixx

Advantages: unlike the previous one it seems to be more thoughtful as a (cough) “thumber” knows that people will see who has voted them down;

Drawbacks: people may be afraid of showing their honest negative attitude to the submission as this is a good way to make enemies with the submitter (who most often watches his post progress).

3/ Non anonymous (with a comment required)

Advantages: an approach requiring much thought and effort; so negative votes are most often well reasoned;

Drawbacks: people do expose themselves to potential revenge (like above) plus in this case negative voting seems to take too much effort (anyway, why should a negate vote be so much harder to cast than a positive one?)

The solution?

Negative Voting - the Solution

The above analysis got me to thinking about a perfect system (ok, nothing is perfect under the sun – at least the best possible combination of the negative voting role and process). So what might that be?

1/ Anonymous (with no need to comment) but also invisible to anyone except a thumber himself = StumbleUpon. Really this model seems one of the best existing – it provides both freedom of the members and healthy sleep of the submission owner. Besides, non-active role of the negative voting allows for this invisibility. After all, thumbs down don’t mean “Your post is bad” – it just means “This article is not too interesting to me but I have nothing against you personally and I do assume that you are a talented blogger“. Besides, in cases of utmost disagreement, you can always show it by commenting your thumb down.

2/ Anonymous (with the required anonymous comment). I don’t know if that model exists, but it seems quite reasonable. It requires some effort and thought (removes “emotional” factor) and at the same time gives some freedom (you are no more afraid of massive revenge).

Any thoughts?

And what are your thoughts and experiences with negative voting across social media you participate?

Post images: under the same sun, dripping cloud, UAE

The following two tabs change content below.
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy LinkedIn profile

Ann Smarty

I am Ann Smarty, owner of SEOsmarty.com. I've been in the SEO industry for two decades. I am the former Editor-in-Chief of Search Engine Journal and a contributor to Mashable. These days I am running Viral Content Bee and writing for Moz, Buzzsumo, Wix and many others!
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy LinkedIn profile

Latest posts by Ann Smarty (see all)

  • Blog Post Checklist: Check All Prior to Hitting “Publish” - Sep 12, 2023
  • 25 Actionable Ideas to Smartly Re-Use Your Old Content (+ ChatGPT Prompts for Each Idea!) - Sep 7, 2023
  • Keywords in Domain Names? How Domains Impact SEO - Aug 29, 2023

Related posts:

  • Twitter Translator, Twitter Tickets, What’s More?
  • Google Trying to Identify the Author: Fails and Puzzles
  • Seven Alternative Keyword Research Tactics to Uncover More Ranking Opportunities
  • Quick SEO Company Evaluation – Don’t Buy it…
  • SEO Slogans: Cool, Sexy And Not Only That…

Post navigation

Previous Previous
Beyond (SEO) Niche Blogging and Branding
NextContinue
Tracking Google Keyword Position (SEJ)

Subscribe!

Also read:

  • How to Create an SEO Strategy for Small Business
  • Digital Marketing Tools: Best New SEO Software I Use
  • How Much Does it Cost to Make a Blog (a Website)?
  • Should You Change Your Profile Picture to Protect Your Privacy?
  • 15 Cartoonists That Allow Using Their Web Comics for Free
  • Impossible CAPTCHA : It Doesn’t Really Matter if You are Human or Not
  • No, You Are NOT Allowed to Use Any Flickr Images
  • How To Optimize Images For Search Engines, Social Media and People
  • 5 Must-Have WordPress Plugins for Perfectly Optimized Images
  • Special Symbols (Wingdings) for Social Media Branding (Twitter, LinkedIn, Google Plus)
  • How to Create a Useful Twitter Retweet Bot
  • How Blocking Users on Twitter, Facebook and Google Plus Works
  • HOW TO: Force Facebook to Grab the Best Image from Your Page (WordPress)

Follow Ann

About Ann

About Ann Smarty

Major places where I contribute and guest blog: Ann Smarty guest blogging

    Social

    Follow me on:

    Join my platform!

    Viral Content Bee

    RECENT ARTICLES

    • Blog Post Checklist: Check All Prior to Hitting “Publish”
    • 25 Actionable Ideas to Smartly Re-Use Your Old Content (+ ChatGPT Prompts for Each Idea!)
    • Keywords in Domain Names? How Domains Impact SEO
    • SEO Video Marketing – An Extra Boost to Your YouTube Videos?
    • Semantic Research + AI = Win
    • A Detailed Guide to Writing Listicle Articles

    MOST POPULAR POSTS

    • How To Optimize Images For Search Engines, Social Media and People
    • How to Create a Useful Twitter Retweet Bot
    • Ann Smarty Becomes An SEO Mom :)
    • Link Building is Still a Numbers Game
    • Am I NOT Allowed to Link (Legally)?
    • How To Call To Action
    • HOW TO: Re-package Your Best Content for More Exposure (and Links)
    • Impossible CAPTCHA : It Doesn't Really Matter if You are Human or Not

    CATEGORIES

    • Blogging
    • Branding
    • Content Marketing
    • Digital Marketing Ethics
    • Domain Names
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Link Building
    • Marketing Tools
    • On-Page SEO
    • Reputation Management
    • Search Engines
    • Social Media Marketing
    • Usability
    • Viral Marketing
    • Website Design

    © 2023 SEO Consulting

    • Infographic Link Building Service
    • Content Marketing Services
    • Guest Blogging Services
    • Contact