Skip to content
Ann Smarty

SEO Consulting

  • Infographic Link Building Service
  • Content Marketing Services
  • Guest Blogging Services
  • Contact
Ann Smarty
SEO Consulting
Home / Search Engines / Google Trying to Identify the Author: Fails and Puzzles

Google Trying to Identify the Author: Fails and Puzzles

Google authorship failsPast weekend was one of the rare occasions when I didn’t go anywhere with my family and decided to stay at home to get prepared for my presentation at soon-to-come PubCon New Orleans where I am speaking on optimizing your content marketing to Google’s authorship and potential Google AuthorRank update.

Hence I had some quality time going through my Author Stats in Google Webmaster Tools Labs and have come across some interesting results I am sharing here.

Table of Contents

  • The Ugly…
  • I am not the author…
  • Google Seems to Know I am into Guest Blogging!
  • Just Puzzled
  • Conclusion

The Ugly…

It’s not a secret that Google is trying to determine the author of non-verified content and they could really a better job:

Google assigns Mashable-scraped article to me (I authored the original Mashable article, not this one):

Scraped content assigned to the author

There’s no way the original article sends fewer positive signals to Google than the scraped one; it’s also verified as authored by me: So why include its scraped version in my article list?

Question: Can a poor full-of-duplicate content site potentially negatively affect my author rank?

I am not the author…

I was really puzzled to see this article assigned to me:

not my article

Yes, I did write a couple of pieces on Advanced Google parameters (Can Google know that?) and one of my articles was for SEOmoz, but not this one!

I am looking at the article, scrolling down to my name and find the possible issue: “Edited by“:

Not my article

Come on Google, that’s just my comment, NOT the whole piece!

Google Seems to Know I am into Guest Blogging!

Ok, I started with “the Ugly”, but this one is a good thing, I guess. Even though, this is another NOT MINE piece (if you take a look, you’ll even see there’s no way to assign it to me as there’s no usual “by” signal Google seems to be liking), the piece mentions guest blogging, MyBlogGuest (which I hope Google knows is mine) and my name – which probably makes Google thinks I am the author!

Google Seems to Know I am into Guest Blogging!

BTW: I know I may be assuming too much here but I see a positive sign that Google isn’t assinging to me just any article I am commenting at, but selects topic that are close to my expertise: advanced search and guest blogging!

Just Puzzled

Ok, I seem to at least be able to guess the reasoning behind the above three fails, but this one? I am puzzled!

Puzzled

I am not a moderator or member of that group; I haven’t posted there once and there’s no mention of my name on that page whatsoever… The only thing: I do know and I am connected to the moderators of that community – that’s the only connection! Still not enough to make me the author of that page 🙂

puzzled

Conclusion

I get it, Google Authorship is still work in progress and Google AuthorRank will remain the future plan until they learn to collect authorship data properly. It’s fun to watch though!

The following two tabs change content below.
  • Bio
  • Latest Posts
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy LinkedIn profile

Ann Smarty

I am Ann Smarty, owner of SEOsmarty.com and co-founder of Smarty.Marketing. I've been in the SEO industry for two decades and I am now reporting on search and AI news over at annsmarty.com
My Twitter profileMy Facebook profileMy LinkedIn profile

Latest posts by Ann Smarty (see all)

  • How Seasonal Trends Inform and Direct Your Content Strategy [Updated] - May 2, 2025
  • Practical Guide to Finding Link Bait Inspiration - Sep 25, 2024
  • How to Get Insanely Productive with Social Media Updates to Scale Your Referral Traffic - May 1, 2024

Related posts:

  • [Updated] Guest Blogging, the Fork and My Take :)
  • Google Home Page and Search Results: Interface Evolution
  • Where I Contribute and Guest Post
  • HOW TO: Re-package Your Best Content for More Exposure (and Links)
  • HOW TO: Force Facebook to Grab the Best Image from Your Page (WordPress)

Post navigation

Previous Previous
Google Home Page and Search Results: Interface Evolution
NextContinue
MyBlogGuest and the Value of the Team

Subscribe!

Follow Ann

About Ann Smarty

Social

Follow me on:

I am Ann Smarty, owner of SEOsmarty.com and co-founder of Smarty.Marketing. I've been in the SEO industry for two decades and I am now reporting on search and AI news over at annsmarty.com

RECENT ARTICLES

  • How Seasonal Trends Inform and Direct Your Content Strategy [Updated]
  • Practical Guide to Finding Link Bait Inspiration
  • How to Get Insanely Productive with Social Media Updates to Scale Your Referral Traffic
  • How to Make Money Blogging in 2024
  • Everything About Passwords – a Guide to Managing Online Personas
  • HOW TO: Re-package Your Best Content for More Exposure (and Links)

MOST POPULAR POSTS

  • How To Optimize Images For Search Engines, Social Media and People
  • How to Create a Useful Twitter Retweet Bot
  • Ann Smarty Becomes An SEO Mom :)
  • Link Building is Still a Numbers Game
  • Am I NOT Allowed to Link (Legally)?
  • How To Call To Action
  • HOW TO: Re-package Your Best Content for More Exposure (and Links)
  • Impossible CAPTCHA : It Doesn't Really Matter if You are Human or Not

CATEGORIES

  • Blogging
  • Branding
  • Content Marketing
  • Digital Marketing Ethics
  • Domain Names
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Link Building
  • Marketing Tools
  • On-Page SEO
  • Reputation Management
  • Search Engines
  • Social Media Marketing
  • Usability
  • Viral Marketing
  • Website Design

© 2025 SEO Consulting

  • Infographic Link Building Service
  • Content Marketing Services
  • Guest Blogging Services
  • Contact