
It is both a funny and sad question that I have to address because so many business owners fall prey to this hype.
While we are still figuring out in which areas AI can replace human employees, three years into the generative AI era have taught us one thing so far: True human expertise and first-hand experience are irreplaceable.
And while the leading AI brands (OpenAI/ChatGPT, Anthropic/Claude, Meta, etc.) are actively hiring SEO experts, many businesses are weirdly asking themselves the same question:
“Can’t AI do SEO for us?”
It sounds ridiculous in the above context, but it is sadly understandable.
The reason for this lies, as always, in overly promotional messaging from people trying to sell their own automated SEO solutions. It is neither new nor surprising. The sad thing is that those people are heard.
Here are very simple questions that will help you find very obvious questions:
If my SEO strategy can be automated through AI, why cannot everyone else (including my competitors) do it?
In other words, if every business (you and your competitors) can buy a $50 solution to automate their SEO strategy, how will yours stand out and deserve visibility?
Why would Google (or an LLM platform) choose to recommend your business if it is doing what everyone else is doing?
The answer is simple: There’s no reason.
Look at this question this way:
- Organic search gives a user ~10 options
- AI answers usually recommend about 5 options
That’s very little space to be surfaced or recommended with a strategy that everyone else can use, isn’t it?
If Claude or ChatGPT drives my SEO strategy, how is it going to be unique?
Here’s the most important thing about generative AI we don’t talk enough about: LLMs repackage existing knowledge; they don’t come up with anything new.
That’s exactly why Google is talking so much about non-commodity content these days. The web is drowning in repurposed content and repackaged tactics.
AI makes things easy, but it never comes up with anything truly original.
If my SEO strategy is easy AND cheap, how can it be competitive?
For as long as I’ve been in SEO (and that’s over 20 years), there has been one thing that has remained true over millions of widely advertised tactics: If it is too easy, it is not going to be effective in the long run.
It is so obvious that it almost doesn’t need any explanation. If it is easy, everyone can do it, so you have 0 edge over your competitors.
So before you make a decision, try to answer these very simple questions. And then decide…
Latest posts by Ann Smarty (see all)
- Should Businesses Still Have In-House SEO Teams, or Can AI (ChatGPT/Claude) Create & Implement SEO Strategies? - Nov 15, 2026
- What Signals of a Quality Web Page: EEAT (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) and More - Apr 13, 2026
- How Seasonal Trends Inform and Direct Your SEO Content Strategy [Updated] - May 2, 2025
